Substituting Yarn for a Pattern
Yarn substitution is one of the most common and most often-mishandled steps in knitting. Done well, the substitute yarn produces a garment indistinguishable from the original. Done poorly, the gauge is off, the drape is wrong, or the yardage runs short.
Recommended A printable technique cheat-sheet for your knitting bag.
Match gauge first
The most important match is gauge: stitches and rows per 4 inches. A substitute with the wrong gauge will produce a garment of the wrong size, no matter how perfectly the colour and weight match.
Match fibre and ply
Wool, cotton, and acrylic produce different drapes at the same gauge. A heavy worsted-spun wool produces a structured fabric; a soft 4-ply cotton at the same gauge produces a draped fabric. Match the fibre type and ply structure to the original where possible.
In partnership Tools and supplies that make this technique easier.
Calculate yardage
A 100 g ball of bulky yarn might be 90 yards; a 100 g ball of fingering might be 400 yards. The pattern's total yardage requirement is what matters, not the ball count. Always calculate yardage before buying.
Buy extra
Always buy at least 10–20% extra yarn — for swatching, for unanticipated mistakes, and for the inevitable need to add a little more length somewhere. Most yarn shops accept returns of unopened balls.
Abbreviation reference
| Abbreviation | Meaning |
|---|---|
| CYC | Craft Yarn Council |
| WPI | wraps per inch |
Tips
- Always match gauge first, fibre second, colour third.
- Calculate total yardage before buying — ball count is misleading.
- Buy 10–20% extra to cover swatches, mistakes, and last-minute changes.
In depth
Yarn substitution succeeds or fails on the gauge swatch. Even an apparently identical yarn can knit up at a different gauge due to ply, twist, fibre content, or even dye lot. The swatch is the only reliable test, and the time spent on it is repaid many times over in the avoided mistakes.